Glimpses of the New West
The Wild West, What Happened to it, and What's Next
By Nathan Bierma

THE NATIVE AMERICANS
BACK | NEXT

Defeat and despair hung in the air even thicker than the winter wind, which blew oddly mild on a late December morning.  Chief Spotted Elk, having recently taken over for Sitting Bull after his death earlier that month, had moved his tribe toward Pine Ridge in what is now South Dakota. But the United States 7th Cavalry caught up with them there and brought the tribe to

Wounded Knee Creek.  Camp was set up with the white flag of truce flying overhead.  On the morning of December 29, 1890, fourteen days after Sitting Bull’s death, the cavalry still had their defeat four years ago at Little Bighorn fresh on their minds, and were doubly restless about the Ghost Dance, the tribe’s ultimate supernatural attempt to recover the dwindling numbers of buffalo and their pre-European freedom.
 
Wounded Knee
 

Wounded Knee, the symbolic completion of European invasion, happened near 
Pine Ridge, South Dakota.Today the Pine Ridge Reservation is the poorest place 
in the country.
 

The cavalry searched the camp to make sure they had seized all the weapons from the Lakota.  A shot was fired – each side would later claim it the other pulled the trigger – and the cavalry’s massacre was on.  Guns, cannons, and swords lay waste to the disarmed men, pregnant women, and terrified children of the Lakota.  When the roar of bullets quieted, more than 250 Lakota corpses covered the camp over a two mile radius. That night the snow fell, and the wind turned cold.  The bodies remained frozen in death for four days before being dumped into mass graves. 

The government handed out over two dozen medals of honor for bravery to soldiers at the scene.  Congress’ investigation ended with a shrug of the shoulders, at the pen of General E.D. Scott: “There is nothing to conceal or apologize for in the Wounded Knee Battle – beyond the killing of a wounded buck by a hysterical recruit.” 

History records it as the last battle between the government and the Native Americans, though the Lakota were deprived of any change to justify their half of that term.  This was mass murder under truce.  By whatever name, Wounded Knee was the final curtain, the symbolic completion of the European invasion. The Ghost Dance, the Native Americans’ last gasp of freedom, had been snuffed out by still more government bullying.  It was the most brutal 
of the U.S. government’s broken promises, 
the bloodiest of their breaches of trust.

Two stone markers stand at Pine Ridge today; plans for a full-fledged memorial park are ironically hung up over the fact that the government must take reservation land away from the Lakota Nation in order to establish the park.  Over a century after Wounded Knee the government remains awkward as it deals with the Lakota Nation.  It would seem, then, that a worthy intercessor would be U.S. President Bill Clinton, whose silk-smooth politicking laughs at awkwardness. 

It’s the economy, stupid,” Governor Clinton’s slogan shouted, the centerpiece of his first presidential campaign.  It was an easy selling point, with the economy mired in an early-decade recession.  Seven years later, with the economy roaring, Clinton would pluck the issue from the shelf and hit the campaign trail again, answering the press’demand to locate a “legacy.”

 “The poverty tour” was the ultimate photo op – a chance for the scandal-weary president to escape the embarrassment of Washington and, flanked by poor children, re-assert that he felt their pain.  The most poignant photo-op of all would come at the seven-city tour’s most prominent stop: Pine Ridge, South Dakota. 

Not since Franklin Roosevelt had a U.S. president set foot on a reservation, but you can’t hold a “poverty tour” without Pine Ridge. Over three fourths of the 20,000 Lakota people on the reservation are unemployed. Almost three fourths of children live below the poverty line.  Average annual income is $4,000. Pine Ridge is a lousy location – too close to the nearby Badlands for farming and too far away from any industries.  Lakota people live 10-20 years fewer than average Americans and suffer rates of infant mortality, suicide, and heart-related death that are twice that of the rest of America. Alcoholism is sky high.

So Clinton would preach about selective prosperity:  Sure, the nation is enjoying unprecedented growth, but it’s no boomtown in places like Pine Ridge.  Not everyone is getting rich off the stock market and swimming in affluence.  Here, notions of IPO’s for new dot coms are miles and eras away.

At Clinton’s side for the trip to Pine Ridge was Andrew Cuomo, Secretary of the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), to ensure the trip would be more than just a camera-bathed stump speech.  Clinton and Cuomo pulled the tarp off a government plan bent on jumpstarting tribal economic growth.  They introduced eight new initiatives promising millions of dollars in mortgages, savings bonds, and grants, as well as job training and Internet access. 

Teach a man to fish, the thinking was, and you will spur his economy.  Just handing the reservation a check would have been helpful but near-sighted.  The trip was hardly shorn of overt political motivations, but it was the most meaningful and highest
profile government promise this generation of Native Americans has seen, coming at the very place where over a century ago the defenseless Lakota’s blood spelled out the story of the final conquest of the Native Americans.
BACK|NEXT


 
 

Pine Ridge, South Dakota
President Clinton's  'poverty tour' 
included a stop at Pine Ridge, where 
three fourths of people are unemployed.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Clinton introduced eight
new initiatives promising
millions of dollars in 
mortgages, savings bonds, 
and grants, as well as job 
training and Internet access. 
Teach a man to fish, the 
thinking was, and you will 
spur his economy. 



Glimpses of the New West
The Land
The Native Americans
The Frontier
The New West

Links
Home


Glimpses of the New West
© COPYRIGHT 1999
Center Field Media
email@cfm.iwarp.com